Bill Paying

When paying your bill, you have several options. You may visit our office Monday-Friday 8:00 am to 4:00 pm. Agency personnel will be happy to process your check or cash payment. Your payment will be processed within two business days. Please check due date. For the carriers listed below, you may remit payment by phone or go online to select additional options

Phone 800-288-8740
Online Payment www.auto-owners.com
-Customer Center
–Select Customer Login Now
Method of Payment EFT, Visa or MasterCard, Electronic Check
Mailing Payment Option 1 – Regular Mail
Auto-Owners Insurance
P.O. Box 30315
Lansing, MI 48909-7815

Option 2 – Overnight Delivery
Auto-Owners Insurance
6101 Anacapri Blvd.
Lansing, MI 48917

Phone 888-333-3956
Online Payment www.mycitizenspolicy.com
-Select payment option
Method of Payment EFT, Visa or MasterCard, Debit Card (Star, Pluse, NYCE, or ACCEL), Electronic Check
Mailing Payment Option 1 – Regular Mail
Citizens Insurance Co of America
Dept. 77360
P.O. Box 77000
Detroit, MI 48277-0360

Option 2 – Overnight Delivery
Citizens Insurance Co of America
c/o J.P. Morgan Chase
9000 Haggerty Rd.
Mail Station MI1-8206
Belleville, MI 48111

Phone 800-425-1100
-Option #1
–Follow prompts
Online Payment www.GrangeInsurance.com
-Under My Grange Account
–Select “Pay My Bill” and choose
—payment options
Method of Payment EFT, Visa or MasterCard, Debit Card (Star, Pluse, NYCE, or ACCEL), Electronic Check
Mailing Payment Grange Mutual Insurance
P.O. Box 740604
Cincinnati, OH 45274-0604
Phone 800-442-8277
-Ext 1572
–Option #3
Online Payment www.HastingsMutual.com
-Click “Policyholder-My Account”
Method of Payment EFT, Visa, MasterCard, Discover, Debit Card (MC or Visa only)
Mailing Payment Hastings Mutual Insurance Co
404 E. Woodland Ave.
Hastings, MI 49058
Phone 888-606-6426
-Ext 1572
–Option #3
Online Payment www.michiganinsurance.com
-Click “Your Account”
–You will need policy #, name on policy and billing zip code
Method of Payment EFT, Visa, MasterCard, Discover, Electronic Check
Mailing Payment Option 1 – Regular Mail
Michigan Insurance Company
Dept. 259801
P.O. Box 259801
Detroit, MI 48255

Option 2 – Overnight Delivery
Michigan Insurance
1700 E Beltline, Suite 100
Grand Rapids, MI 49525

Phone 800-876-5581
Online Payment www.Progressiveagent.com
-Select “Make a Payment”
Method of Payment EFT, Visa or MasterCard, Electronic Check
Mailing Payment Drive Insurance
P.O. Box 7247-0311
Philadelphia, PA 19170-0001
Phone 800-733-3320
-Option #3
–Follow prompts
Online Payment payments.wolverinemutual.com
-You will need policy #,last name on policy and billing zip code.
Method of Payment EFT, Visa, Discover or MasterCard, Debt Card – (MC or Visa only)